Daniel Pastorek died nearly three years ago, on Thanksgiving Day, 2020, in a mental health unit in the Allegheny County Jail. He struggled with housing and suffered from schizophrenia. He was arrested and booked at the jail after failing to appear for an appeal in magistrate’s court on a public drunkenness case. He was 63 years old.
Since April 2020, 20 men have died following their incarceration at the Allegheny County Jail. A month after his death, a public information request was filed for Pastorek’s autopsy. Nearly three years later, that request was granted after a 6-1 decision by the Commonwealth Court determined the county must provide the records to this reporter.
The Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office did not conduct a full autopsy, or surgical procedure, to determine Pastorek’s cause and manner of death. Instead, an ‘external review’ of Pastorek’s body was performed, concluding that he died of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease based on his “clinical history of cardiac issues,” “alcohol abuse” and “mental health issues.”
“They didn’t do an autopsy—they didn’t perform one. They did an external examination. They looked, they took his temp, they found he had no injury,” said Roger Mitchell, the chief medical examiner of Washington D.C. He is the co-author of ‘Death in Custody: How America Ignores the Truth and What We Can Do about It.
Mitchell said an internal review of a cardiac event, or full autopsy, “is one of the rare cases” in which a pathologist can determine when the heart attack happened and how long it took for emergency services to respond.
The four-page external review does not indicate that Pastorek died in the jail. Nothing in the records provided by the medical examiner describe when or how he was found, when he was incarcerated, or that he died in custody. The review also does not indicate how Pastorek’s referenced medical history was obtained or in what manner it was determined.
Guidance on when a full autopsy is conducted varies from county to county across the Commonwealth, as do the inclusion of narratives describing the circumstances of a death in a coroner or medical examiner’s report.
The decision to conduct a full autopsy is at the pathologist’s discretion, according to both state law and county policy, but, some pathologists and researchers argue a full internal examination should be conducted each time an individual dies in custody.
“A complete autopsy is virtually always performed,” for those who die in the jail, Williams said, “Unless the death is clearly natural based on a long-standing and well-documented medical history. Even then, the office will sometimes perform an autopsy.
Pennsylvania law only requires an autopsy to be conducted if, during the course of an investigation, a cause or manner cannot be determined, according to Scott Grim, Executive Director of the Pennsylvania Coroners Association.
Mitchell is principal investigator of the The National Association of Medical Examiners’ white paper, “Deaths in Custody,” a guide for investigations which recommends that there should be, “a lower threshold than normal to perform autopsy examinations on deaths in custody.” The information gathered from autopsies conducted for natural deaths could help lower the mortality of prisons, the report concludes.
Without a full autopsy and narrative, researchers and journalists cannot analyze trends across jail deaths or jurisdictions, according to Terence Keel, who has reviewed hundreds of autopsies of law enforcement deaths in his nationwide research for the BioCritical Studies Lab at the University of California, Los Angeles.
“They’re weaponizing your access which prevents you from telling the whole story. They’re promoting a vision of them as a law-abiding jail facility and a law-abiding death investigation system, by only releasing files that put them in a positive light. It is using death records to their advantage,” Keel said.
Mitchell was more conservative in his assessment of the information provided by the county in regard to Pastorek’s death. A natural death determination indicates that an investigator ruled out someone harming the deceased, he said.
“If there was this major appearance of neglect, that death investigation would continue until it remedied the neglect. A natural death that got an external examination is telling you that there are no untoward circumstances that the medical examiner saw to lead to the person’s death,” Mitchell said.
Jonah Walters, post-doctoral researcher under Keel, is based in Pennsylvania and has reviewed autopsies from county jails across the state. Even a natural death, such as a heart attack, should be considered preventable and raise questions, he said.
“This is a 63-year-old who died of a preventable, treatable, disease–he died under constant supervision, with immediate access to healthcare. The fact that he’s died of an apparent heart attack, or of cardiovascular disease in those circumstances demands an explanation,” he said.
Pastorek’s records are the first inmate death records made public in Pittsburgh under Allegheny v Hailer. In August, PINJ submitted a request to the medical examiner for the autopsies of 16 men who died after entering the jail. That request is pending.
SUPPORT NEWS YOU TRUST. Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.
- The Bye Bye Barry Amazon Prime Video Release Date
- How to Watch Island Season 1 Online: Streaming Details and More
- A Grand Jury Indicts Duane Keith “Keffe D” Davis in Connection with the Killing of Tupac Shakur
- Borussia Dortmund Tops Bundesliga Table with 3-1 Victory Against Hoffenheim
- Benfica Advances to Basketball Champions League Regular Season
- Borussia Dortmund Defeats Hoffenheim 3-1 in Bundesliga Showdown
- Naira Exchange Rates Latest Update Today
- Alucard Makes a Surprising Return in Castlevania: Nocturne Season 2
- The New Order in Road Construction: Senator Dave Umahi’s Fight Against the Old Order
- Neymar Fails to Convert Penalty as Al Hilal Secure Victory
- FC Barcelona Condemns Unjustified Attack by Sevilla FC
- Manchester United and Chelsea Interested in Young Flamengo Star Lorran
- Man Charged with Murder of Rapper Tupac Shakur
- Saudi Pro League: A Platform for Football Excellence
- What’s Happening to Karim Benzema at Al-Ittihad?
- Al Ittihad Striker Karim Benzema Struggles with Injury
- Sir Michael Gambon: A Versatile Actor Who Left His Mark in Film and TV
- Al Nassr Aim for Victory in Saudi Pro League Clash Against Al Ta’ee
- The History of Soccer in Africa: A Journey of Passion and Progress
- Saudi Pro League: An Ambitious Investment in Soccer