Foreign

Google’s fight against EU antitrust fine comes up against critical judge

Published

on


Google’s battle against a 2.6-billion-dollar European Union (EU) antitrust fine recorded an apparent setback on Thursday, when one of the judges hearing the case said the company had committed a “clear infraction”.


The comments by Colm Mac Eochaidh, one of the panels of five judges, said that Google committed a clear infraction in its handling of price-comparison shopping services.

Irish judge Mac Eochaidh came on day two of a three-day hearing at Europe’s General Court, its second-highest, as Google (GOOGL.O) seeks to overturn the first of a trio of EU antitrust penalties.

In its 2017 decision to impose a 2.4 billion euro (2.6 billion dollars) fine, the European Commission said the world’s biggest internet search engine unfairly favoured its own price-comparison shopping service over smaller European rivals.

However, Mac Eochaidh concurred, saying: “For me, this case really is visibility. This is a very important point in the case.

“It is perfectly apparent what has happened is this, you have promoted your own service and demoted that of others, that is a clear infraction.”

Mac Eochaidh repeatedly asked Google what it had refused to supply to its competitors that had forced them to air their grievances to EU enforcers.

Google’s lawyer Christopher Thomas faulted the Commission for not taking Amazon (AMZN.O) into account when defining the market for assessing the competitive harm caused by Google’s practices.

Thomas Hoppner, lawyer for several German complainants, said regulators were right to discount Amazon’s role.

“Merchant platforms and CSSs (comparison shopping services) simply cater to different needs of different types of online retailers.

“These different needs mean that CSSs cannot easily be transformed into merchant platforms and vice versa.

“The entire Google story that the condemned conduct was a means to compete with Amazon has no merits,” Mac Eochaidh added.

Judges are expected to issue their ruling in 2021, which can be appealed to the Court of Justice, Europe’s highest.

The case is T-612/17 Google and Alphabet v Commission.

Edited By: Abiodun Oluleye/Emmanuel Yashim

https://nnn.ng/googles-fight-against-eu-antitrust-fine-comes-up-against-critical-judge/

Stakeholders call for more technology-driven innovations in insurance industry Sane sidelined for Germany and Bayern Munich with knee injury Roma great Totti meets girl who woke from coma after his message Reappointment: ITF staff praise D-G for good stewardship Buhari inaugurates Itakpe-Ajaokuta-Warri rail line, directs construction of rail network to nation’s ports Ogun to settle workers’ outstanding entitlements, says Gov. Abiodun  Ekiti Assembly passes bill to upgrade college of education to university Capital market, organised private sector players reflect on [email protected] UNICEF receives 115, 800 COVID-19 test kits to fight pandemic in Nigeria [email protected]: Agric expert urges FG to adopt climate change policy  Road accidents claim 217 lives in Ogun in 8 months  NAPE chief tasks media professionals on accuracy in reportage COVID-19: CBN introduces healthcare intervention scheme 20 ships discharging petrol, other items in Lagos port – NPA WHO describes 1m global coronavirus deaths as `very sad milestone’ Teenager flees Plateau to escape child marriage, rescued by FIDA Ekit Sports very essential in wealth creation — Nnawugo U.S Institute, Daily Trust hold roundtable on role of media in peace building PIB: Scrapping NNPC not appropriate — Expert COVID-19: private school owners to benefit from N125m loan in Kwara Assault: Court sentences recovering drug addict to 6 months imprisonment  Buratai tasks army officers on professionalism, prudent management of finances Alleged culpable homicide: El-Zazaky pleads not-guilty in Kaduna Ortom gets new adviser on LG and chieftaincy affairs World Heart Day: Stress management vital for healthy heart – Ikokwu Ondo Governorship: APC says Mimiko seeking third term Nigeria requires ideal national [email protected] 60: – ACCI President Harvest: Farmers raise alarm over activities of off-takers, middlemen in Gombe State German doctor admits to years of blood doping Former IMF director, Rodrigo Rato acquitted of investment fraud NGO steps up campaign to end campus cultism by 2023 Oyo: NDE trains 1,650 unemployed youths on vocational skills Table Tennis: Durban to host 2023 World Championships Merkel seeks limits on gatherings, alcohol restrictions against COVID-19 2 accountants in court for allegedly stealing employer’s N12.1m Road crashes, fatalities worry RTEAN— Scribe NASS resumption: CSO demands passage of electoral act amendment bill  Court remands businessman for alleged armed robbery  Women farmers want increased budgetary allocation to agriculture No fewer than 235 golfers expected at IGC Captains’ Inaugural Tournament Nigeria @ 60: Examining Nigeria military in tackling internal security challenges Driver in court for allegedly swindling businessman of N400,000 Environmentalist harps on measures to achieve circular economy in Nigeria TB: Stakeholders call for increased awareness in Nigeria, engage media Thailand’s ‘rule breaker’ school uniforms challenge tradition [email protected]: Power Sector as the Key to National Prosperity Olorunda LCDA gets new supervisor, 3 SAs in minor cabinet reshuffle Ticket racketeering, a booming business at Rigasa, Idu railway stations – NAN investigation Kwara begins 2019 promotion interview for workers Ahmadu Bello University begins full commercial agriculture– VC