The corruption in the award of Petroleum contracts in Nigeria, DRC and Senegal



Investors need to know that their investments are safe and that they will be protected by the law in case the other parties falter on their obligations


Last week, a commercial court in the United Kingdom gave reason to a claim by engineering company Process and Industrial Developments Ltd (P&ID), which demands over USD$9 billion from the Nigerian government over a failed gas deal. The decision follows a 2017 arbitration award and turns it into a legal judgment, which could allow P&ID to seize Nigeria’s international commercial assets.

P&ID’s claim is based on a 2010 contract signed with the government of Nigeria for the construction and operation of a “gas processing plant to refine natural gas (“wet gas”) into lean gas that Nigeria would receive free of charge to power its national electric grid,” the company’s website states. Under the deal, the Nigerian government should have provided the necessary infrastructure and pipelines needed to supply gas to the plant. P&ID would build the plant for free and then operate it and commercialize the output for a period of 20 years.

The company claims that over this period it would have earned USD$6.6 billion in profit, an incredible figure that becomes ever more fantastic as the company claims that the yearly 7% interest it is supposedly charging on this capital has now accrued to USD$2.4 billion, at the rate of USD$1.2 million a day, which closes the full amount at a perfectly round USD$9 billion.

The whole situation is in itself extremely puzzling. Afterall P&ID, a company created specifically for this project, is claiming it is entitled to the full amount of what it would have gained over a period of 20 years of work, even though that period would not be over for another decade and some.

Further, it is already charging interests on capital it would, if the project went forward, it would still be a decade away from generating. On top of that, it has chosen to pursue the matter in a British court and has a separate law suit in an American court, when the contract was signed in Nigeria, under Nigerian law, and should be pursued in a Nigerian court, as the Nigerian legal team has repeatedly stated.

Nigeria is seeking an appeal to the decision, but P&ID is not wasting any time in trying to seize Nigerian assets abroad, and it might well manage to do so, at least in part.

Further, P&ID has never even broken ground on the construction of this power plant, which it claims would have benefitted so many thousands of Nigerians. The company has reportedly spent USD$40 million on preparatory work, although it is impossible to attest what that work has been.

Even just looking to the amount spent, work is done and compensation sought, the figures seem simply absurd. USD$9 billion corresponds to 20% of Nigeria’s foreign exchange reserves, it would be unthinkable that a nation-state would pay that much capital to a small unknown enterprise that invested not but a small fraction of that amount in the country and done none of the contracted work. Further, it is perplexing that a British court would even consider such a decision.

However, this issue represents an important cautionary tale for African governments everywhere. Very few things matter more in the struggle to attract investment and build a favorable business environment that will push the economy forward than the absolute sanctity of the contracts signed.

Investors need to know that their investments are safe and that they will be protected by the law in case the other parties falter on their obligations, as it seems to have happened with the Nigerian government. It is by no means the first time a situation like this happens. Just in March, an international court ordered the Democratic Republic of Congo to pay South African DIG Oil Ltd USD$617 million for failing to honor two oil contracts.

This is an unacceptable and unjustifiable loss of capital for the people of the DRC. Particularly taking into account that the loss is incurred because the country’s leaders failed to comply with a contract that could have brought a considerable amount of wealth for the country for many years to come, in both royalties and taxes, as well as help develop its oil industry.

Senegal’s government under President Macky Sall was very smart to avoid this kind of litigation when it was confronted with the issue of the Timis Corporation and its ownership of acreage that included the Tortue field, which is estimated to contain more than 15 tcf of discovered gas resources.

If President Macky Sall would have proceeded with terminating a valid contract for the acreage, the Timis Corporation would have engaged in arbitration and would have probably gotten a favorable judgment against Senegal. In the process, the gas fields would have sat dormant and produced no returns for Senegal and its citizens. Sometimes leaders are confronted with tough choices and it takes a profile in courage to find solutions and still respect the sanctity of contracts.

Even with criticism from civil society groups, Equatorial Guinea has honored contracts with U.S. oil companies that many oil analysts believe are unfavorable to the state. This principle has kept Equatorial Guinea’s oil industry stable and US firms continue to invest in new projects like the EGLNG backfilling project with Noble, Atlas Oranto, Glencore Marathon and the state.

African leaders and African nations can not afford this sort of mistakes anymore. If on the one hand, contracts must be respected, protected and followed through, the people in charge of evaluating and signing those contracts must have the project’s feasibility as the dominant reasoning behind any decision. What is the purpose of signing contracts for fantastic projects where there is neither the capital nor the conditions to pull it through? Our economies live out of their reputation too. No investor wants to work in a system where contracts are not honored and where their investments are not protected.

While P&ID’s request for USD$9 billion in compensations seems absurd, companies that see the contracts they sign with African governments, or any governments, disrespected, must have the right to claim compensation, just in the same way that African leaders must be responsible for the contracts they sign and must make sure that situations like this do not repeat themselves. Enough money has been wasted on lawsuits that could be used to benefit the lives of Africans. This is true for the oil and gas industry and in any other industries.

NJ Ayuk is the CEO of Centurion Law Group, Executive Chairman of the Africa Energy Chamber, author of the upcoming book, Billions at Play: The Future of African Energy and Doing Deals.

Distributed by APO Group on behalf of Centurion Law Group.

Nj Ayuk

Nj Ayuk: NNN is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor[at]nnn.ng. Disclaimer.

Latest News

WHO Africa Online Press Briefing on COVID-19 in Africa The African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA); A key to mitigate the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic in Africa (By Chido Pamela Mafongoya) GE Secures Equipment Contract to Power the Biggest Power Plant in Senegal African Development Bank’s climate resilient project in Zambia wins water change maker award Unique and more essential than ever NBA All-Star Voting presented by AT&T tips off Thursday, Jan. 28 Coronavirus: UK in Cameroon COVID-19 Relief Caravan World’s largest survey of public opinion on climate change: a majority of people call for wide-ranging action Canon announces launch of Africa Frontiers of Innovation Series 2021 Minister of Foreign Affairs announces Canada’s contribution to the United Nations Peacebuilding Fund As Sub-Saharan crises force more to flee, UNHCR calls for stronger Mediterranean route response Coronavirus – Gambia: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Coronavirus – Zambia: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Coronavirus – Kenya: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Coronavirus – Ethiopia: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Amen Healthcare and Empowerment Foundation invites the press to a roundtable on neglected tropical diseases (NTDs), mass drug administration, and WHO 2030 NTD roadmap Coronavirus – Eswatini: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Bill and Melinda Gates Release 2021 Annual Letter: “The Year Global Health Went Local” Supersapiens and Team Qhubeka ASSOS Announce Partnership AstraZeneca is recognised as a Top Employer 2021 in South Africa and Kenya Coronavirus – South Africa: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Moussa Faki Mahamat and Mohamed Ibn Chambas concluded a joint visit to Sierra Leone and Cabo Verde Coronavirus – Zimbabwe: COVID-19 update (26 January 2021) Coronavirus: African Union Member States reporting COVID-19 cases as of 26 January 2021, 9 am EAT eLife Publishes AIMS Researcher’s Paper on HIV Treatment Coronavirus – Malawi: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) Coronavirus – Ethiopia: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) Coronavirus – Nigeria: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) Coronavirus – Zambia: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) Coronavirus – Kenya: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) 34th AU Summit strives to leverage and valorise African Arts, Culture and Heritage Signing of memorandum of understanding (MoU) Between Development of the Private Sector (ICD) and SQB Securities, Uzbekistan New African Development Bank-Global Center on Adaptation (GCA) initiative will galvanize $25 billion to scale up African climate adaptation Africa's top business leaders to participate in awards to celebrate India's republic day to independence day Register to hear Musa Kalenga on leapfrogging tech in Africa at #BizTrends2021 Unstoppable Paule Ella Guei honoured with Sports+ Award Her Excellency Fatoumata CM Jallow Tambajang and her commitment to serve the people of Africa Coronavirus – Rwanda: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) Coronavirus – Gambia: COVID-19 update (25 January 2021) Kenya adopts Trusted Travel digital tool for COVID-19 test result verification Coronavirus: African Union Member States reporting COVID-19 cases as of 25 January 2021, 9 am EAT Coronavirus – Uganda: COVID-19 update (24 January 2021) Beyond COVID: Prioritizing NTD agenda and sustainable local financing International Islamic Trade Finance Corporation (ITFC) announces the launching of the 2nd phase of the Aid for Trade Initiative for Arab States (AfTIAS 2.0) in June 2021 to Mitigate the Effects of COVID-19 on Trade in the Arab Region Coronavirus: African Union Member States reporting COVID-19 cases as of 24 January 2021, 6 pm EAT New Report on African media shows western sources dominate how the Africa story is told Coronavirus – Malawi: COVID-19 update (24 January 2021) Coronavirus – Kenya: COVID-19 update (24 January 2021) Coronavirus – Zambia: COVID-19 update (24 January 2021) Sudan kicks off second response campaign against polio outbreak