Africa Should Rethink Business Models For Impact And Sustainability



News Today 2

Article by Babatunde Oyateru

Corporate Identity Crisis

NAIROBI, Kenya, 15 September 2021-/African Media Agency (AMA)/-It is no secret that humans anthropomorphise everything; perhaps it is down to the urge to make things more relatable or our need to recreate.

Whatever the case, many inanimate, abstract concepts now bear personalities. Because of this, we can think of organisations with personas, and we argue that they should be responsible corporate citizens. In recent times, there has been a tension between the different personalities we have imbued our corporations with, which has resulted in an identity crisis if you will.

Is the corporate goal of an organisation solely to return a profit to its shareholders, or should it be purpose-driven and respond to wider societal needs at the expense of robust profits?

As the world confronts the fragility of the current consumption-based economic system with the attendant environmental effects and perpetuating inequality, it has turned more and more to sustainability and societal impact as a possible alternative.

The conversation on sustainability, however, has not sufficiently addressed the dichotomy presented by attempting to create impact economies with corporations not designed to deliver impact.

What is in a Name?

Corporations are largely delineated into two broad categories: those driven by profit and those driven by social impact. Those driven by profit are usually pragmatic and efficient, with little concern for other indices beyond the bottom line.

Companies motivated by social impact defy maximising profit and aim to improve the quality of life. What is becoming evident however, is that the delineation cannot be absolute.

Private corporations can no longer pursue profit while ignoring the social, political and environmental effects their business has. Neither can Impact or development institutions claim to be adherent to social goals but promote inefficiency in delivering their services.

Best practice seems to be shifting to the middle-ground, a hybrid between the need to run profitable enterprises which have a broader impact on the communities they serve.

Thought leaders like Dirk Schoenmaker, the Rotterdam Professor of Banking and Finance, have called for an impact economy that recognises these often-divergent urges and coalesces them to improve corporate citizenship and improve the quality of life of customers, end-users, consumers and ultimately the country.

Achieving this Impact Economy is often easier said than done, as corporate citizenship is often reflective of the economy and regulations of a country.

Redefining the Structural Space

Most companies conduct their business either in a market economy where the government provides public goods, such as health, education and security and regulates economic activities. However, private companies are geared towards profit-maximisation and usually at the expense of a more profound impact.

Or companies operate in a state economy where the government controls the production of private and public goods ostensibly to ensure broader service provision but usually at the expense of efficiency and individual enterprise.

In Africa, where the distinction between the private and public sectors is becoming less obvious and more transparent and where private corporations that thrive do so with considerable government incentivisation, it is often difficult to tell the difference between the two systems.

What is clear is that either system or a combination of both have contributed to environmental degradation, economic inequality, and reduction in the quality of life in Africa.

A possible solution to this will be redefining the economic structure and, by extension, the companies they foster; Schoenmaker refers to this as the Impact Economy.

The Impact Economy coalesces the distinct features of the market economy and those of the state economy which seeks broader participation of both the public sector and the private sector in the provision of goods and services.

This model actively encourages considering the common good and general welfare without sacrificing the self-sufficiency and growth of private enterprises.

Striking the Right Balance

Admittedly, the impact model appears self-indulgent and wistful, but it is not without precedent. Indeed, development financial institutions (DFIs) and development agencies are founded principally on the ideals of impact investing and sustainability, all while funding their operations.

It is little wonder that most of these institutions are openly financing the achievements of the relevant United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in their industries and have done so while promoting profitability.

Recently JP Morgan committed itself to invest in the SDGs and launched a DFI in 2020 that has so far channelled $146bn to development projects worldwide.

This is not to suggest that striking a balance between a shrewd investment philosophy, greater risk appetite and a mandate for development and profit is easy- just that it is possible and already exists in some ways.

To be fair, it may be asking African governments to take on more than they are able for now, but this is one of the specific roles DFIs can play.

DFIs demonstrate the delicate balance needed for impact investment and advance the conversation on repurposing African organisations for impact and sustainable development.

DFIs can also revisit what states should consider a public good; for instance, decent and affordable housing should be regarded as a public good in the same way education and health services are. Making these distinctions will broaden the space for impact investment as well.

The SDGs, if achieved by 2030, will serve all of humanity but perhaps Africa more than most. As countries task themselves with closing the SDG funding gap which stands at $2.5trn according to a UNCTAD report, they should also be concerned with reshaping organisations to help deliver them.

About the author:

Babatunde Oyateru is a Communication and Development Professional who heads Communication and External Affairs for Shelter-Afrique, a Pan-African DFI. He is also a Doctoral Candidate in International Relations

Short Link:


NNN: :is a Nigerian online news portal that publishes breaking news in Nigeria, and across the world. Our journalists are honest, fair, accurate, thorough and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting news in the best interest of the public, because truth is the cornerstone of journalism and they strive diligently to ascertain the truth in every news report. Contact: editor @

Recent Posts

African Union, RECs and RMs meet to coordinate the implementation of the continental integration agenda African Development Bank holds second virtual seminar on business opportunities for 2021, with special country on Angola The rise of social media in Nigeria Frank Fannon, former United States Assistant Secretary of State for Energy Resources, will be the keynote speaker at African Energy Week in Cape Town UNDP trains, empowers 525 youths, women in Adamawa States’ nonchalance to 10 million out-of school-children worrisome — Academic The “Civil Society Capacity Building Program” was carried out in Congo with the support of TİKA Alleged Lekki Killings: Nigerian govt demands apology from CNN, Amnesty Int’l Buhari, Turkish President in bilateral talks in Aso Villa US government supports socio-economic development and youth leadership initiatives in Cabo Delgado Statement on the situation in Ethiopia Ethiopia: UN expresses concern as air strikes kill 9 Benzema absent as sex tape blackmail trial begins #EndSARS: 11 states submit final reports on rights violations by SARS operatives – FG Olympic flame arrives in Beijing for 2022 Winter Games Cape Town partners with Africa Energy Week 2021 for continent’s premier energy event Insurance companies to pay N20bn #EndSARS protest destruction claims – Official Protecting the privacy of health data is essential for health equity in Africa (By Christopher A. LeGrand, Rachel Clad and Ruan Viljoen) Lekki massacre is a phantom conspiracy, Nigerian govt insists Indonesia, China begin feasibility study on $560m coal-to-methanol plant Mbappe, Messi found their groove after PSG’s comeback win against Leipzig Bangladesh slams developed nations over decades of climate ‘empty pledges’ Taliban reaffirms commitment to preventing security threats for foreign countries India’s PM inaugurates new airport to boost tourism The International Islamic Trade Finance Company (ITFC) signs a 100 million euros Murabaha financing agreement with SENELEC, dedicated to supporting Senegal’s energy sector Former German soldiers held for planning mercenaries for Yemen Court fixes Nov. 22 for arraignment of ex-Aviation Minister, Stella Oduah Court fixes date for arraignment of ex-Aviation Minister Stella Oduah Paradigm Initiative publishes a short film “FOCUS” calling for the vigilance of citizens to protect digital rights UN needs to play central role in normalisation of situation in Afghanistan Canada-Africa collaboration: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to address Africa accelerating 2021 QSL Gas & Power CEO places natural gas at the center of Africa’s energy transition during African Energy Week in Cape Town Imo community set to honour Actor Kanayo with chieftaincy title FCT lawmaker trains 520 constituents on mechanized farming Inna Ciroma, other aspirants submit nomination forms ahead of PDP National Convention Africa Oil Week will highlight unparalleled opportunities, boost investment and deal making on the African continent Buhari greets ex-Head of State, Yakubu Gowon, on 87th birthday Ancient Hebrew prayer book auctioned for $8m Benzema absent as sex tape blackmail trial begins Banditry: Army operations have returned farming activities in Kebbi – Bagudu Automatic inspection system for imagePRESS C10010VP series enhanced to read variable data, barcodes and QR codes The 26 best young African entrepreneurs selected for the new three-year Anzisha Prize scholarships Direct Carrier Billing Index reveals the most favorable countries for DCB growth in the MEA region Red Cross renovates 12 houses destroyed by floods in Katsina Private varsity partners European private sector to curtail youth migration  –VC North Korea tested new ‘submarine-launched ballistic missile’: KCNA Democrats, Biden negotiate intensively on saving ambitious agenda Micronutrient deficiency: HarvestPlus to develop zinc enriched maize, rice Snake bite: Victims’ survival slimmer as anti-venom prices soar – Expert Kano police arrest suspected fuel suppliers to bandits in Katsina